Granny Fay’s Pie Shop

Welcome to Granny Fay’s Pie Shop. Here we use a mix of teachings from both of Jeanne’s Grandmas (and a bit of her own added in) to craft the most delicious pies in the Midwest. May the joy of baking from both Granny Doris and Grandma Fayla be passed on to you and your family.

Granny Fay's Pie Shop

Apple Pie
$22.95
Add To Cart
Banana Cream Pie
$23.95
Sold Out
Add To Cart
Blackberry Pie
$22.95
Add To Cart
Blueberry Lemon Pie
$23.95
Sold Out
Add To Cart
Cherry Pie
$22.95
Add To Cart
Chocolate Cream Pie
$23.95
Sold Out
Add To Cart
Coconut Cream Pie
$23.95
Sold Out
Add To Cart
Key Lime Pie
$23.95
Sold Out
Add To Cart
Mixed Berry Pie
$22.95
Add To Cart
Strawberry Cream Pie
$23.95
Sold Out
Add To Cart
Chicken Pot Pie
$25.95
Add To Cart
Crumb Topping (Add-on)
$2.00
Add To Cart (once you select your pie)