Welcome to Granny Fay’s Pie Shop. Here we use a mix of teachings from both of my grandmas (and a bit of my own added in) to craft the most delicious pies in the Midwest. May the joy of baking from both Granny Doris and Grandma Fayla be passed on to you and your family. Enjoy!

Pickup Locations:

Cultivate Coffee + Health Bar
28522 S Kauffman Rd, Garden City, MO 64747

Artisan’s Corner
101 W Wall St, Harrisonville, MO 64701

  • Delicious pies, savory and sweet, obviously made with love and pride. Delightful and friendly service as well.

    Alan Cox

  • Ordered 3 pies for thanksgiving, best pies I’ve ever had!!

    Misty Lorton